Mamma Mia! Reviews

Mamma Mia! has an overall rating of 1.8 based on 27 reviews. Customer feedback on Mamma Mia! is mixed.

1.8/5.0

27 reviews

5 Stars

0

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

4

1 Star

17

All Mamma Mia! Reviews (27)
JosephFlansburg_25
June 02, 2026
"Nice spot, but the drink choices were lacking"
The place was nice overall and the staff seemed friendly, which I appreciated. That said, the drink options were limited, no iced tea and mostly just basic sodas, which was a little disappointing. I’d still consider coming back, but I really hope they add a few more drink choices.
JosephScungio
May 26, 2026
"Nice variety on the menu"
They’ve got a good mix of pizzas, pasta, and sides. took me a minute to decide what to get, but like… in a good way.
ChaseDabe
May 19, 2026
"Expected better for the price"
I ordered dinner from mamma-mia.com thinking it would be a decent treat, but it really didn’t live up to what I expected. The pizza arrived barely warm, the base was chewy, and the toppings tasted a bit cheap rather than fresh.
The pasta was even more disappointing. The sauce was watery and bland, and after a few bites I just stopped eating. Maybe they were having an off night, but for the price, I expected much better and probably won’t order again.
ruby_Grace02
May 16, 2026
"Honestly, easy site to use"
The site was simple to get around and the pages loaded without any problems. It did take me a minute to find the menu, but overall I didn’t really run into any big issues.
josephnewman5104
May 15, 2026
"Pasta was underwhelming"
I ordered from mamma-mia.com last Friday night because I was craving a decent pasta dinner, but it was kind of disappointing. When it arrived, the delivery part was totally fine and on time, but once I sat down to eat, the pasta just didn’t hold up. The noodles tasted overcooked and mushy, like they’d been sitting around for a while, not fresh at all. The sauce was okay, but by a few bites in, it still wasn’t enough to make the meal enjoyable. For what I paid, I expected it to be a lot better. I kept thinking maybe it would grow on me, but by the end, I was just wishing I’d ordered something else.
michael.Hickman
May 02, 2026
"I was really looking forward to..."
I was really looking forward to the cake, but it ended up being a letdown. It tasted like it had been sitting around for a while, not in a fresh-from-the-bakery kind of way, but more like it had dried out and lost that soft texture you expect. I kept hoping maybe the next bite would be better, but it was just consistently dry and a little stale-tasting. Not the worst thing I’ve ever had, but definitely not something I’d order again.
FOLEY
April 30, 2026
"Small portions made the whole thing stressful"
The food tasted okay, but the portions were way too tiny for what I paid. I wasn’t expecting dinner to turn into this annoying little stress spiral of wondering if I’d need to order more food afterward.
david.Santiago
April 27, 2026
"The pizza just didn’t seem fresh... the toppings..."
The pizza just didn’t seem fresh... the toppings were kind of soggy, and the whole thing tasted a bit old and off.
belinda.Gregory
April 12, 2026
"My card ended up getting charged..."
My card ended up getting charged twice, and support still hasn’t sorted it out. On top of that, I kept getting these pushy reminder messages like I hadn’t already paid, which just made the whole thing even more frustrating. Really not a great experience.
yvette_Girard02
March 27, 2026
"I tried it out last week because I..."
I tried it out last week because I figured the higher price meant I’d be getting something better. At first, the site seemed fine and easy enough to use, but after spending some time with it, I just didn’t feel like I got much for what I paid. By the next day, I was already thinking I probably could’ve found something similar for less somewhere else. Nothing really stood out to me, so for me the value just wasn’t there. 1 star.
WillieNelson_60
March 25, 2026
"Staff took forever to respond"
The food was fine, nothing amazing but not bad either, though the whole experience got annoying because every time I had a question or needed something it felt like I was waiting forever for someone to notice or respond, and when they did it didn’t really seem like they cared much, so it wasn’t the worst place I’ve been to but I definitely wouldn’t call it a great experience.
Ann-farmer
March 06, 2026
"I had a small issue and was a..."
I had a small issue and was a little worried it might turn into an expensive hassle, but they got it sorted out quickly. Nice to have it fixed without feeling like I was being charged for every little thing.
WICKER
March 05, 2026
"Reservation seemed confirmed, but clearly wasn’t"
I booked a table through Mamma Mia! and got the confirmation, so I figured everything was sorted. But when we showed up, the restaurant had no record of it at all. The staff tried, but you could kind of tell they didn’t have much to work with, and we ended up waiting around for ages. Reading between the lines, the booking system just doesn’t seem reliable. Frustrating experience, and I wouldn’t use it again
MILLER
February 28, 2026
"Just too loud and squeezed in"
I don’t know, the place didn’t really feel good to sit in. The music was super loud, the tables were like too close to each other, and it felt more messy than cozy. I was kind of just sitting there not relaxing at all. So yeah, I don’t think I’d go back...
david2004
February 28, 2026
"Cold food, missing garlic bread, and not worth the money"
I ordered takeout from mamma-mia.com and felt like I just threw money away. The delivery showed up late, the pizza was already cold, and the garlic bread I paid for wasn’t even in the bag, which was really frustrating.
I tried calling to get it sorted out, but nobody answered. The pasta was soggy too, like it had been sitting there forever. I hate paying for a meal and feeling like I got less than what I ordered, so I definitely won’t be ordering from here again.
marilyn_Taylor73
February 26, 2026
"I ordered from mamma-mia.com and was really looking..."
I ordered from mamma-mia.com and was really looking forward to it!! But the food showed up almost an hour later than the time they gave me. It tasted okay, but the long wait kind of ruined the whole experience for me.
anneyork6493
February 25, 2026
"Ridiculously slow delivery"
Delivery from mamma-mia.com was a joke. The arrival time kept changing over and over, and by the time the food finally showed up, it was almost 2 hours late.
I get that restaurants get slammed, but these guys acted like total amateurs with no real update and not even a simple sorry. Food was cold by then, so yeah, I’m definitely not ordering from them again.
MauriceGertz_68
February 12, 2026
"Online ordering was such a hassle"
I placed an order online and it just never showed up. What made it more annoying was that there wasn’t any clear communication about what was going on—no real update, no explanation, nothing. I was left guessing whether it was delayed, canceled, or just lost somewhere. Really frustrating experience.
carolynsanchez2588
February 10, 2026
"Not a great first impression with the pricing"
The whole pricing setup gave me a bad first impression. I thought I had a clear idea of what I was paying, but then extra fees showed up later in the process. It felt annoying and kind of misleading
BruceDickens_08
February 08, 2026
"I ordered from mamma-mia.com the other night because..."
I ordered from mamma-mia.com the other night because I didn’t feel like cooking after a long day, and I was really just craving a decent pizza while watching a show. Delivery was totally fine and showed up without any drama, but the pizza itself was a letdown. The crust was kind of dry, and the cheese tasted a bit bland, almost like it had been sitting around too long. The sauce was okay, but there wasn’t much flavour overall. Not the worst pizza I’ve ever had, but I probably wouldn’t rush to order from them again

View More Reviews

Have a question about Mamma Mia!?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.